Health

A hair loss brand with strong SEO but weak AI presence: what the gap revealed

ChatGPT · Perplexity · Gemini · Google AI Overviews October 2025
68
out of 100 across tested queries

Situation

A hair loss brand with a clinical positioning and good organic search rankings was tested for AI visibility. Despite high keyword rankings for category queries, the brand tested below the median score in the Jeevan AI benchmark cohort. This suggested that SEO performance does not directly translate to AI visibility, particularly in health-adjacent categories.

What Was Tested

Queries tested covered hair loss causes, treatment options, ingredient efficacy and brand comparisons. The brand had strong content around its own products but limited mentions in independent clinical or editorial sources.

Testing was done using a standard query set across all four platforms. Results can vary between sessions, so treat the patterns here as directional rather than definitive. We don’t name the brand to keep the focus on the signals, not the company.

Platform Breakdown

ChatGPT not cited

Not cited in tested queries. Clinical claims without third-party corroboration may reduce citation likelihood on this platform.

Perplexity cited

Cited in some queries, likely due to SEO rankings feeding into live retrieval. Citation context was limited.

Gemini not cited

Not cited in tested queries. Low Knowledge Graph entity coverage appeared to be a factor.

Google AI Overviews cited

Appeared in one triggered query. Structured FAQ content on the brand website appeared to contribute.

What the Testing Suggested

Signals That Appeared to Matter

Frequently Asked Questions

Why would a brand rank well in SEO but poorly in AI visibility?
SEO ranking reflects how well a page is optimised for search engine crawling and ranking algorithms. AI visibility depends on whether AI models have encountered reliable, consistent information about the brand across many independent sources. A brand can rank highly through technical SEO while having limited AI-friendly entity signals.
Do clinical claims help AI visibility for health brands?
In testing, clinical claims that are supported by independent sources, such as published studies or editorial coverage in health publications, may help. Claims that appear only on brand-owned pages appeared less impactful in tested queries on platforms like ChatGPT.
What is the difference between Perplexity visibility and ChatGPT visibility?
Perplexity retrieves live web content when answering queries, so brands with strong SEO rankings may appear even if they are absent from ChatGPT's training data. ChatGPT relies primarily on its training data and any retrieval tools in the current session. The two platforms can therefore give very different visibility outcomes for the same brand.

How Does Your Brand Score?

Run an AI visibility scan across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews.

Check Your Brand Free