Situation
A widely distributed skincare brand available across major Indian e-commerce platforms was tested for AI visibility. The brand had strong retail penetration but its online entity information was inconsistent: ingredient lists, product descriptions and brand origin details differed across third-party retailer pages. In testing, this appeared to create ambiguity for AI platforms when assembling brand-level responses.
What Was Tested
The brand was tested across a set of queries covering skincare recommendations by concern (dry skin, oily skin, anti-ageing) and ingredient-based queries. Platform-level citation rates and the nature of mentions were recorded across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini and Google AI Overviews.
Testing was done using a standard query set across all four platforms. Results can vary between sessions, so treat the patterns here as directional rather than definitive. We don’t name the brand to keep the focus on the signals, not the company.
Platform Breakdown
Cited consistently in recommendation queries. Entity clarity and Wikipedia presence appeared to be key factors.
Cited frequently. SEO rankings and structured content on retailer pages appeared to contribute.
Cited in some queries. Google Business Profile completeness appeared correlated.
Not consistently triggered for this category. When triggered, the brand was not included in tested queries.
What the Testing Suggested
- In testing, the brand was cited on 3 of 4 platforms, suggesting a reasonable baseline entity presence.
- Tested queries on ChatGPT returned consistent citations, which may indicate that well-corroborated third-party sources were already present in its training data.
- Perplexity citations appeared to track with the brand's retailer page rankings, suggesting that live web retrieval may amplify distribution-based visibility.
- Gemini citations appeared less consistent, which in testing correlated with a partially-completed Google Business Profile.
- Google AI Overviews did not trigger for most of the tested skincare queries, limiting the data available for that platform.
Signals That Appeared to Matter
- Consistent entity information across retailer pages
- Wikipedia or Wikidata entry with verified facts
- Organisation schema on brand homepage
- Ingredient and product data structured in a machine-readable format
- Third-party editorial mentions beyond brand-owned content
- Complete Google Business Profile